Pessimists Archive Newsletter

Share this post

Pessimists Archive Newsletter: Before the AI Panic

newsletter.pessimistsarchive.org

Pessimists Archive Newsletter: Before the AI Panic

Before AI, teachers and artists panicked about new tech

Pessimists Archive
Jan 15
14
Share this post

Pessimists Archive Newsletter: Before the AI Panic

newsletter.pessimistsarchive.org

📏 Breaking the Rules

Concern about Chat-GPT kicked off the year with NYC School District blocking it on school computers. This brought to mind protests from teachers in the past about computers, calculators, Wikipedia and Google.

The article above - written in 1984 - discusses the decline in popularity of the slide rule and its replacement by electronic calculators and computers. The article quotes John Strack, a physics teacher at Arlington, who said "You can program a computer to perform a certain task, then you can train anybody to punch numbers into it. But if you don't teach him the concepts, how will he learn to program the computer himself?" Other technologies, including the internet caused similar concerns about what this means for educating children and young adults:

Thanks for reading Pessimists Archive Newsletter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
.@theguardian, 2000: "Is this a student's work I see before me - or just a ready-made, paid-for download from the internet? It's a question starting to bother lecturers and one that won't go away."
Image
9:30 PM ∙ Jan 14, 2023
44Likes14Retweets
Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
The New York Times, 2006. That photo 🤣
Image
1:09 PM ∙ Jan 11, 2023
75Likes17Retweets
Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
"Linda O'Connor regards Wikipedia the same way former first lady Nancy Reagan campaigned against drugs." "Wikipedia is blocked on all computers in the Warren Hills Regional School District." web.archive.org/web/2007112421…
Image
Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
1981 https://t.co/se3dNc7rlj https://t.co/bS2v7jZwpC
3:16 PM ∙ Jan 6, 2023
30Likes6Retweets
Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
1981
Image
Twitter avatar for @hardmaru
hardmaru @hardmaru
Even if schools ban Generative AI, students everywhere will still learn to use this technology, because they won’t let schooling interfere with their education.
10:36 PM ∙ Jan 5, 2023
1,177Likes225Retweets
Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
Image
2:29 PM ∙ Jan 6, 2023
7Likes1Retweet

📸 Everything is a Remix

Generative AI has been creating a similar stir to ChatGPT, there are questions about fair use and copyright - with a new class action lawsuit just filed on the matter. Astrid Wilde pointed out these concerns mimic backlash to music sampling in the 1980s.

Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
1989
Image
Twitter avatar for @astridwilde1
Astrid Wilde ☼ @astridwilde1
the moral panic about AI art right now is a perfect historical parallel to the moral panic by musicians when sampling became a thing
2:36 PM ∙ Dec 29, 2022
79Likes21Retweets
Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
Some hot takes on sampling music: "I think sampling in rap music is disgusting. It's way overused. I think it's definite copyright infringement and it's the absolute opposite of creativity." (1990)
Image
Image
Twitter avatar for @astridwilde1
Astrid Wilde ☼ @astridwilde1
the moral panic about AI art right now is a perfect historical parallel to the moral panic by musicians when sampling became a thing
2:20 PM ∙ Dec 28, 2022
99Likes18Retweets

Another part of the conversation seems to long for a time when artistry was free from technology, an artistic good old days. Yet the camera obscura was used by artists as far back as the 16th century to create more life like images.

Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
Technology is removing the need for skill in art
Image
11:33 PM ∙ Jan 9, 2023
216Likes50Retweets

If you thought the good old days of art was pre-16th century, you’d be wrong - in 2001 famed British artist David Hockney floated a theory (Hockney-Falco thesis), in a book titled ‘Secret Knowledge: Rediscovering the Lost Techniques of the Old Masters’ that argued similar techniques drove the rise of realism in the 14th century. As usual the supposedly techno-dystopian present isn’t as strange and unfamiliar as it may seem. What we’re seeing now has played out numerous time thorough history:

Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
“The end of art 1930s style” - @_johannezz
Image
Image
Image
Image
10:15 PM ∙ Dec 16, 2022
480Likes130Retweets

⌨️ Not My Type

🔎 NEW DISCOVERY: An 1898 article titled "The Typewriter in Social Correspondence" argued that resistance to using typewriters for personal correspondence will inevitably come to an end. It began "it is going to take time for people to outgrow the prejudice existing against the typewriter as a medium of stating correspondence - between lovers and friends."

The writer acknowledges some prefer the individuality and sentimentality of hand-written letters, but argues that typewritten letters have many advantages over hand-written ones. The article posits that this prejudice will disappear over time, since "typewritten letters are much more legible than when written by hand with a pen" , that they are "without blots as too often appear in manuscript letters” and "typewriting requires but little practice and comparatively no study." On top of all this, he points to the fact typewritten addresses would mean less undelivered mail and posited that wide spread use for personal correspondence would “increase the demand for typewriters” meaning “they would be much cheaper than they now are."

The typewriter would eventually win out - as predicted - and it would be blamed for the “decay of letter writing.”

Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
Typewriter blamed for decline in letter writing: "The typewriter began the demotion of the gentle art of correspondence" (1906) newspapers.com/clip/34421423/
Image
12:23 PM ∙ Jul 31, 2019
60Likes32Retweets

🎉 Unhappy New Year

Our new years themed post struck a cord and performed really well - take a read and make sure you don’t waste your resolutions on harmless new trends that have been framed as sins by the enemies of modernity.

Twitter avatar for @PessimistsArc
Pessimists Archive @PessimistsArc
New Years Resolutions: 2022: - Read more books - Ride the bicycle more - Read in bed, instead of going on phone 1902: - Read less books - Stop riding the bicycle so much - Don't read in bed Via our newsletter: newsletter.pessimistsarchive.org/p/19th-century…
Image
Image
Image
Image
2:10 PM ∙ Jan 1, 2023
355Likes90Retweets
Pessimists Archive Newsletter
19th and 20th Century New Years Resolutions
By @louisanslow - Curator of Pessimists Archive In the 20th century, certain habits that are now considered GOOD and even necessary for a healthy lifestyle were seen as unhealthy. We listed habits that are now considered good that people may have committed to stop as a new year's resolution 100 years ago…
Read more
3 months ago · 6 likes · Pessimists Archive

Thanks for reading Pessimists Archive Newsletter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Share this post

Pessimists Archive Newsletter: Before the AI Panic

newsletter.pessimistsarchive.org
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Pessimists Archive
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing